15 Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes: Reviews & Guide

Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes

MamiesSkinCare.com is reader-supported. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission

Ladies, I’m sure you’re all well aware that good mascara is a must-have in any makeup kit. It doesn’t matter if you are at work every day or out with friends on a Saturday night, you deserve the perfect product. Mascara can make your lashes pop and revolutionize your look!

Some mascaras irritate your eyes, causing pain and discomfort. If you’re looking for the best mascara to use on sensitive eyes, we have a list of the best recommendations below!

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents
    Scroll to Top

    Our Top Picks for the Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

    Regular mascaras cause redness and irritation in sensitive eyes. You need gentle mascaras. It can also make you look as if you’re constantly crying. You can avoid this by choosing one of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes listed below.

    #1. Maybelline Makeup Full ‘n Soft Washable Mascara

    Our Pick

    Maybelline is a well-trusted beauty brand, and this mascara doesn’t disappoint! It’s an excellent choice for those who are looking for hypoallergenic mascara at a reasonable price. It also contains vitamin E which creates an advanced thickening formula that will instantly give your lashes a full, bold look.

    This mascara comes in a dark, intense black shade that will give you a bold look. Quick Dissolve System Technology ensures it’s easy to rinse off. It is an ophthalmologist-tested product.

    #2. Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

    Smudge and Flake-Free

    With this excellent Neutrogena product, you will have longer, stronger lashes without irritation. It contains a unique combination of ingredients like vitamin E and olive oil that nourish your lashes. These will protect your lashes from damage, flaking, smudging, and clumping with a bold look that will last all day.

    #3. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara

    Powered With With Jojoba Oil

    Burt’s Bees is another leading brand in the beauty industry. This product is 100% natural and comes with an extremely easy-to-use applicator. It also comes in two great colors so you can choose between a bold black or classic brown to suit your preferences. It is dermatologist tested.

     It contains jojoba oil which moisturizes your lashes. This product also contains glycerin to help your lashes look bold and beautiful.

    #4. Eco Bella All-Natural Black Mascara

     Vegan Mascara

    The Flower Color Natural Mascara has a gentle formula so you don’t have to worry about irritation. This mascara is vegan and cruelty-free. It also doesn’t contain parabens or fragrances. 

    It is convenient to have a mirror in the tube to help you apply it anywhere, any time. Purified water, flower cutins with iron oxides, and carnauba are some of the main ingredients in this product. It is also ideal to wear contact lenses.

    #5. Vivienne Sabó Paris - Classic French Mascara

     Cruelty-Free Product

    Vivienne Sabo Paris is the perfect mascara for anyone who wants long-lasting volume with a touch of length and no clumping! This easy-wearing formula won’t leave you feeling weighed down all day. Plus, it’s waterproof so no need to worry about your mascara running when the weather turns bad!

    The brush is small enough to coat every lash evenly, while still being large enough for those with shorter eyelashes. The best part is that washes off easily at night so there’s no damage done to your gorgeous eyelashes during removal!

    You can rest assured that this product’s quality is unsurpassed. It is cruelty-free and doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals that could irritate your eyes. 

    The mascara is available in 4 shades which makes it a great choice for unique, bold looks.

    #6. Skin2Spirit Natural Mineral Mascara

     Hypoallergenic

    This mascara is hypoallergenic ensuring it’s perfect for those with sensitive eyes. This mascara will give your lashes more length and thickness, while also preventing irritation.  It is an ophthalmologist-tested product.

    It does not contain lead, dye, or petroleum which is good news for sensitive skin. You can also use this product like an eyebrow pencil meaning it gives you double the benefits!

    #7. EVXO Mineral Mascara

     Powered with Coconut Oil

    With this product, it’s possible to increase lash length and volume without resorting to chemical-laden products. This mascara is can handle anything life throws at it! It will make you stand out from the crowd and is another great option if you want to wear contacts.

     It is cruelty-free and contains a unique blend of natural ingredients including coconut oil which helps keep your lashes hydrated and healthy. It comes in a bold jet black color, which is great for dramatic looks. You can use a thin layer if you prefer a more subtle look. It has a smudge-free formula. If you have easily irritated eyes then this is one of the suitable products.

    #8. Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara

    Flake Free Formula

    This product is a great option to help you achieve silky, defined lashes?   It is water-resistant which helps you stay flawless even in bad weather. It also doesn’t contain the usual chemicals that other products use to prologue the life of the product and contains all-organic environments instead.

    It contains high-quality botanicals which add life and volume to your lashes. Many users also love the smooth application which is perfect for people who are impatient with applying eye makeup.

    #9. Marcelle Xtension Plus Mascara

    Fragrance-free

    This mascara is hypoallergenic and non-fragrant. It promises to curl your lashes quickly and adds length. It has a double-sided wand that makes it easy to apply.  It has an eyelash lengthening formula.

    This mascara doesn’t clump so it won’t look shabby even after being worn for hours. The Canadian Dermatology Association recognizes it as a high-quality product safe for sensitive skin, so you can use it with peace of mind.

    #10. RevivaLabs Hypoallergenic Mascara

     Tear-Proof

    Many people love it because it’s a great mascara for your eyes. It has fibers that thicken and lengthen lashes, while still looking natural. The mascara is tear-proof and does not contain any chemicals that irritate your eyes.

    It is gentle enough for contact lens wearers. RivivaLabs is a company with almost 50 years of industry experience, so you can trust that their products will work.

    #11. Ere Perez Natural Avocado Mascara

     24-Hour Wear

    Avocado is more than just for toast, it’s also a great mascara ingredient! This product is different than most of the others we’ve listed because it contains avocado as its main ingredient. It is a smudge-proof product. 

    It doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals or toxic ingredients like paraffin, parabens, propylene glycol, and phthalates. It is also highly durable and will last whatever the day throws at you. The manufacturer states that it can be worn for up to 24 hours without reapplying. It has an eyelash lengthening formula.

    #12. Physicians Formula Organic Wear Jumbo Lash Mascara

     Ophthalmologist Approved

    You can rest assured knowing that this product contains 100% natural volumizing technology. It will nourish and moisturize your lashes without irritating them.  It is hypoallergenic and even ophthalmologists approve it!  

    This mascara contains natural ingredients such as aloe leaf extract and olive leaf extract, soy oil, carnauba wax, carnauba honey, and orange water. These ingredients won’t cause irritation or redness. The eco-brush is 100% recyclable ensuring this is an environmentally conscious purchase. It does not contain mineral oil.

    #13. Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara Supernova

    Powered With coconut oil and vitamin B

    This volumizing mascara is 100% vegan so you can rest assured that it will be a great choice for sensitive skin. It separates the lashes and increases volume, making them appear thicker.  You can use this product even if you have dry eyes.

    It contains vitamin B and coconut oils, which are great for strengthening and hydrating your lashes. It is also free of parabens, phthalates. Many users adore how soft and comfortable the applicator is.

    #14. 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra-Lengthening Mascara

     Contains Pro-vitamin B5

    This mascara receives its bold, black color without the use of harsh chemicals and coal tars like most products on the market. Instead, it uses black tea to give you a dark look while increasing the volume of your lashes. This vegan, cruelty-free, eco-friendly mascara is perfect for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. It is suitable for contact wearers.

    Pro-vitamin B5 is an ingredient responsible for strengthening the eyelashes for maximum health. Blackberry will give your mascara more vibrancy and shine. The product also contains seaweed to create thicker, bolder lashes. It is allergy tested and won’t give you itchy eyes.

    #15. Endlessly Beautiful All-Natural Organic Mascara

    Free From Harmful Chemicals

    This volumizing mascara is a great choice for adding volume to your lashes. It is safe for sensitive eyes as it contains 100% naturally derived ingredients and 85% organic. This mascara is cruelty-free so that you are assured it has not been subject to any animal testing. It gives you natural-looking lashes.

    What to Look for in Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes

    Here are the top factors you should consider to make the best decision.

    Take a look at the ingredients:

    Look for products that contain natural ingredients, rather than toxic chemicals that are harmful to the eyes.

    Go Fragrance-Free:

    Also, the mascara should be free of fragrances. Most mascaras contain fragrance-enhancing chemicals which can irritate.

    Choose Hypoallergenic:

    To ensure that your sensitive eyes are not affected, you should look for a product labeled as hypoallergenic.

    FAQs - Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

    What are the Symptoms of Eye Sensitivity to Mascara?

    The symptoms of sensitive eyes can vary from one person to another. If your eyes are sensitive to mascara you may experience itchy, teary eyes. Your eyes may also become red and swollen.

    Which Ingredients Should be Avoided?

    Avoid chemicals and preservatives as these can irritate your eyes. Avoid products that contain toxic thickening agents and artificial fragrances. If you want peace of mind, choose simple, basic, natural, and organic ingredients.

    How Do You Apply Mascara on Sensitive Eyes?

    Avoid touching the roots of your lashes as this will increase your likelihood of irritation. It is best to brush it on the ends, and not directly onto the skin. An eyelash curler is a great option to reduce the amount of mascara you need to apply.

    Conclusion

    All mascaras are not the same. There are many differences, especially in the ingredients as these are the most likely culprits if you experience teary, red eyes with mascara. You should be cautious when selecting the right product for you and try to opt for natural formulas.

     To make an informed decision that you will not regret, pay attention to the products we highlighted above.

    Emma Smith

    Emma Smith

    I am Emma Smith a freelance beauty and wellness writer. I graduated from New York University, where I studied English Literature and Creative Writing. After working in the beauty industry for several years, I decided to pursue my passion for writing about things related to beauty and health - from skincare tips to makeup tutorials to interviews with leading experts on the field. I have also done dermatology course 'Dermatology: Trip to skin' from Novosibirsk State University (NSU).

    I love staying healthy by doing working out and yoga. I am mother of a beautiful baby girl, I spend most of my time caring for her while still managing work obligations.