15 Best Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes: Reviews & Guide 2021

Ladies, I’m sure you can relate to my statement that a good mascara is a must-have in any makeup kit. It doesn’t matter if you are at work every day or out with friends on a Saturday night, this is something that you must have. Mascara can make your lashes pop!

If you’re looking for the best mascara to use on sensitive eyes, we have the best recommendations.

Our Top Picks for the Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

Regular mascaras can cause redness and irritation in sensitive eyes. It can also make you look as if you’re constantly crying. You can avoid this by choosing one of the listed mascaras.

#1. Maybelline Makeup Full ‘n Soft Washable Mascara

This mascara is made by a trusted drugstore make-up brand. It’s an excellent choice for those who are looking for hypoallergenic mascara at a reasonable price. It also contains Vitamin E which is responsible for the advanced thickening formula. You will notice a difference in the thickness of your lashes immediately after applying it. This mascara comes in a dark, intense black shade that will give you a bold look. Quick Dissolve System is a technology that makes it easy to clean off mascara. It is safe to use once you have rinsed it.

#2. Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

You may already have enough reasons to consider it over other products on the market. You will have longer, stronger lashes and it won’t be too harsh on your sensitive eyes. It contains a unique combination of ingredients that provide nourishment for the lashes. These include Vitamin E and olive oil. It is not easily damaged by flaking, smudging or clumping and can last all day.

#3. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara

This mascara is made by a company known for natural beauty products. It is 100% natural. It contains jojoba oil, which is one of the main ingredients. It can moisturize your lashes and make them look more healthy when combined with glycerin. It’s easy to apply mascara with the convenient applicator. You can choose between classic black and classic brown colors to enhance your lashes.

#4. Physicians Formula Organic Wear Jumbo Lash Mascara

You can rest assured knowing that this product contains 100% natural volumizing technology. It will nourish and moisturize your lashes without causing irritation. Even ophthalmologists have approved it. It is hypoallergenic and has been specifically labeled. This means that it does not contain any ingredients that could cause severe side effects. This mascara contains natural ingredients such as aloe leaf extract and olive leaf extract, soy oil, carnauba wax, carnauba honey, and orange water. It’s also great that the eco-brush is 100% recyclable.

#5. Naturally Rooted Premium Organic Mascara

Although it may not come from the same brand as those mentioned, you can rest assured that its quality is unsurpassed. It is organic at 85% and doesn’t contain any harmful chemicals that could irritate your eyes. It is free from gluten, dyes and fragrance. It uses only natural ingredients, like chamomile oil and sunflower oil. These two oils are well-known for their moisturizing properties. The mascara is available in a rich black color which makes it a great choice for bold looks.

#6. Skin2Spirit Natural Mineral Mascara

If you have sensitive eyes, this mascara is hypoallergenic. This mascara will give your lashes more length and thickness, while also preventing irritation. It is hypoallergenic due to its formula. It does not contain lead, dye, or petroleum. This is good news for sensitive skin. This product can also double as an eyebrow pencil.

#7. EVXO Mineral Mascara

It is possible to increase lash length and volume without resorting to chemical-laden products. This mascara is living proof. It is cruelty-free, and contains a unique blend of natural ingredients. Coconut oil is added to the mascara, which helps keep your lashes hydrated and healthy. Its jet black color is a great thing. This mascara will make you stand out from the crowd. You can use a thin layer if you prefer a subtle look.

#8. Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara

Do you want silky, defined lashes? This product should also be on your shopping list. It is water-resistant. It is water-resistant, so you can be certain that it doesn’t contain any chemicals that are used to prolong mascara’s life. It contains organic ingredients. It contains high-quality botanicals which can add life and volume to your lashes. Many users loved the smooth application. This makes it an excellent choice for people who are impatient with applying makeup.

#9. Marcelle Xtension Plus Mascara

This mascara is hypoallergenic and non-fragrance. It promises to curl your lashes quickly and add length. It has a double-sided wand that makes it easy to apply. It doesn’t clump so it won’t look shabby even after being worn for hours. The Canadian Dermatology Association recognizes it, which can give you peace of mind.

#10. RevivaLabs Hypoallergenic Mascara

Many people love it because it’s a great mascara for sensitive eyes. It has fibers that thicken and lengthen lashes, while still looking natural. The mascara is tear-proof and does not contain any chemicals that could irritate your eyes. It is gentle enough to be used even by people with contact lenses. It is also made by a company with almost 50 years of industry experience, so you can trust that their products will work.

#11. Ere Perez Natural Avocado Mascara

Avocado is more than just for toast! Avocado can be used in mascara ingredients! This product is different than most of the others we’ve listed, because it contains avocado as its main ingredient. The organic ingredient can improve lashes. It doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals or toxic ingredients like paraffin, parabens, propylene glycol and phthalates. It is also durable. The manufacturer states that it can be worn for up to 24 hours without needing to be reapplied.

#12. Eco Bella All-Natural Black Mascara

The Flower Color Natural Mascara has a gentle formula so you don’t have to be concerned if your eyes are sensitive. This mascara is vegan and cruelty-free. It also doesn’t contain parabens or fragrances. It is convenient to have a mirror in the tube. This will let you instantly see what it looks like. Purified water, flower cutins with iron oxides and carnauba are some of the main ingredients in this product.

#13. Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara Supernova

This mascara is 100% vegan so you can rest assured that it will be a great choice for sensitive eyes. It can separate the lashes and increase volume, making them appear thicker. It also contains Vitamin B and coconut oils, which are great for strengthening and hydrating. It is also free of parabens, phthalates, and similar to other products we have reviewed. Many users have commented on how the mascara’s brush applicator is soft and comfortable.

#14. 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra-Lengthening Mascara

It is not due to any harsh chemicals or coal tar that this mascara can achieve deep black pigmentation. It is because of the black tea leaves that it can achieve this color. These dark pigments can increase the volume of your lashes. Pro-Vitamin B5, the ingredient responsible for strengthening the eyelashes, is also included. Blackberry will give your mascara more vibrancy and shine. Seaweed is another natural ingredient you’ll find in this mascara. It adds thickness. These ingredients work together to create a cruelty-free, eco-friendly mascara that is gentle on your sensitive eyes.

#15. Endlessly Beautiful All-Natural Organic Mascara

This mascara is a great choice for adding volume to your lashes. It is safe for sensitive eyes, just like the other mascaras mentioned. It is actually 100% natural and 85% of it organic, according to the manufacturer. This mascara is cruelty-free so that you are assured it has not been subject to any animal testing.

What to Look for in a Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

Here are the top factors you should consider to make the best decision.

Take a look at the ingredients:

Look for products that are made with natural ingredients, rather than toxic chemicals that can be harmful to the eyes.

Go Fragrance-Free:

Also, the mascara should be free of fragrances. Most mascaras contain fragrance-enhancing chemicals.

Choose  Hypoallergenic:

To ensure that your sensitive eyes are not affected, you should look for one that has been specifically labeled hypoallergenic.

Avoid Waterproof:

Certain chemicals may be added to mascara that is waterproof. This can cause irritation of the eyes.

Mascara for Sensitive Eyes FAQs

What are the Symptoms of Eye Sensitivity to Mascara?

It can vary from one person to another. It can cause itchy, teary eyes. Your eyes may also become reddened and swollen after an allergic reaction.

Which Ingredients Should be Avoided?

Avoid chemicals and preservatives. They can cause irritation. Avoid products that contain toxic thickening agents and artificial fragrances. If you want peace of mind, choose simple or basic ingredients.

How Do You Apply Mascara on Sensitive Eyes?

Avoid touching the roots of your lashes. This will cause irritation. It is best to brush it on the ends, and not directly onto the skin. To reduce the amount of mascara you need, an eyelash curler is a good option.


All mascaras are not the same. There are many differences, especially in the ingredients used. You should be cautious when selecting the right product for you. To make an informed decision that you will not regret, pay attention to the products we have highlighted above.

Check out other category articles

Scroll to Top